The Prague Post
May 17th, 2008
Reader's SurveyNEW     Endowment Fund     Book of Lists ONLINE      Reservations      Classifieds    Subscriptions
Real Estate Prague Prague Rentals Prague Apartments Prague Art & Antiques


Communist Youth defends rights

Two years after being banned, group is ordered to dissolve

By Markéta Hulpachová
Staff Writer, The Prague Post
April 30th, 2008 issue

VLADIMÍR WEISS/THE PRAGUE POST
Members of the KSM, which is openly affiliated with the KSČM, voiced support for communist symbols at a rally in Brno in early April.
enlarge
One cannot walk through the Prague headquarters of the Communist Youth Union (KSM) without facing Lenin and Che Guevara. Loosely taped to the lackluster walls, their colorful portraits meet visitors at every turn. When trying to avoid their haunting stares, one is inevitably bombarded by the revolutionary slogans occupying the last inches of wall space, urging the masses to mobilize against capitalistic extortion in a confetti of languages.
The organized mess throughout the dormlike office suggests that the union’s members have been busy: Nearly all flat surfaces are piled high with fliers and random papers, and the constricting conference room is littered with chairs leftover from well-attended meetings.
But even as the group prepares for its annual participation in the traditional May Day demonstrations organized by the Communist Party of Bohemia and Moravia (KSČM), the days of its existence as a registered civic organization are numbered.
On April 24, the KSM — an organization of approximately 600 members — received a ruling of the Prague City Court ordering its immediate dissolution. As its leaders struggle to postpone the decision by filing an appeal with the Supreme Court, the verdict represents the culmination of a three-year battle between the KSM and a group of government officials who maintain its existence threatens democratic ideals.
The initiative to dissolve the KSM dates to 2005, when senators Jaromír Štětina and Martin Mejstřík filed a criminal complaint against the anonymous authors of several articles published in Mladá pravda (Young Truth), the KSM’s official publication.
Convinced that the publication’s statements conflicted with democratic principles, the senators claimed the KSM had violated a law prohibiting the propagation of a movement aimed to suppress personal rights and freedoms.
“In the publication, the KSM alludes to Lenin, to Marxism-Leninism and its appellation to practice class warfare,” Štětina said.  
To illustrate his concerns, he cited an article alleging that “unified [Marxist-Leninist] theory and practice are the leading star of the proletarian revolution,” essentially condoning the revolutionary rhetoric of the founding fathers of communism.  
Upon the conclusion of a police investigation in which both senators were interrogated, the Interior Ministry ruled to dissolve the KSM in May 2006, citing the unconstitutionality of an article in the union’s official agenda seeking to “abolish the private ownership of the means of production” and “overthrow capitalism through revolution.”
Despite its fruitless correspondence with the Interior Ministry and its recently unsuccessful appeal to the Prague City Court, which stalled the dissolution for two years, the KSM refuses to surrender the fight for its existence.
“We are planning to submit a complaint to the Supreme Court,” said Ludvík Šulda, the 28-year-old chairman of the KSM’s advisory club. “If that doesn’t work, we’re willing to take it as far as [the International Court of Human Rights] in Strasbourg, but we’re hoping it won’t come to that.”
Šulda says the increasingly anti-communist sentiments of the Czech government and society are behind the banning of the KSM.
With individuals like Milan Paumer, a former anti-communist resistance fighter, visiting schools and voicing anti-communist sentiments, it is little wonder that KSM members feel persecuted for their beliefs, he said.
“Far-right organizations such as the National Party and the National Resistance movement publicly voice their antipathies toward democracy, and they are still allowed to operate,” Šulda said. “[The government] condones the existence of one mouse while banning the other.”
Political convictions aside, the KSM leadership believes the ministry’s decision is a flagrant violation of the freedom of speech and assembly.
“The actions of the Interior Ministry aroused a strong reaction from abroad,” Šulda said. “Hundreds of youth organizations, unions and [EU politicians] have voiced their disapproval. … Banning us is nonsensical, because it’s not going to change our opinions.”
Ironically, both the KSM and its opponents in the Senate invoke democratic principles in their chief arguments.
While the KSM clings to the democratic staple of the freedom of expression, Štětina argues that the organization’s agenda endangers the very existence of democracy by acting as the radical appendage of the Communist Party.
“In practice, the KSM actually represents a handful of loudmouths and politically confused young people who are hardly dangerous to the young democracy of our state,” he said. “What’s dangerous is that KSM is being used to promote the violent solution of societal problems, which is something the KSČM cannot afford to do by itself for tactical reasons.”
Radical youth
Both the KSM and the KSČM openly admit to their long-standing affiliation.
The KSM’s Prague offices are housed in the same building as the KSČM headquarters, and approximately half of the youth union’s members end up joining the KSČM, according to Šulda.
 Speaking at a KSM congress in March, KSČM Chairman Vojtěch Filip expressed his hopes that “the people who passed through the ranks of the KSM will compose the new blood of the KSČM.”
Meanwhile, young people throughout the country continue to identify with communist beliefs.
“Even after the ruling of the Prague City Court ordered its dissolution, membership in the KSM has increased,” Šulda said.
As he mulls the uncertain fate of his organization in the dusty confines of the Prague branch office, Šulda’s opinions seem moderate next to the convictions of the young communists in poorer regions like Bruntálsko, north Moravia, whose Web pages are decorated with a portrait of notorious Soviet dictator Josef Stalin.
“Youths are always radical in their views, but you have to excuse them because they are young and inexperienced,” said Statis Prusalis, a prominent KSČM member and an avid supporter of the communist youth movement in north Moravia. “They haven’t done anything terrible enough to warrant the actions of the Interior Ministry. I am convinced that time will rule in their favor.”

Markéta Hulpachová can be reached at mhulpachova@praguepost.com


survey banner


Other articles in News (30/04/2008):

Browse the Current Issue

If you enjoyed this article, why don't you subscribe to the print version!
We accept secure online transactions provided by PayPal and Moneybookers

Reader's comments:

add your comment
[08:50 02/05/2008] : This is rather typical of western "democracies". Every party is allowed, so long as it is capitalist. The United States has taken this to an extreme, with what is essentially a one-party system which uses fake "wedge issues" to create the illusion of choice.
Margot Winston
Prague
[16:14 02/05/2008] : This is not an accurate statement regarding the United States.
There are actually people registered as members of a communist party (and other parties) that appear upon our ballots at times. They are never taken seriously, of course (and thank God).
There really are many different political views in the United States, but the two dominant parties play toward the middle to get 51 percent of the vote.
So it does appear to an outsider that there is not much choice.
But, if I were to start to discuss what I think is wrong in American politics, we might be discussing a PhD dissertation.
I simply wished to correct Ms. Winston's false statements.
"Youths are always radical in their views, but you have to excuse them because they are young and inexperienced," - this is a very true statement.
Richard Elliot
Charlotte
[02:43 03/05/2008] : Lenin and Che Guevara are symbols of a system that has raped the Czech Republic and Slovakia. A system that has sapped the spirit of entrepreneurism, created an atmosphere for corruption, incarcerated millions, and murdered millions more.

Che Guevara was a coward who murdered people with relish. He was the executioner for Fidel Castro. When he was cornered in South America, he ordered his men to fight to the death while he snuck out and gave himself up to federal troops.

You all should remember the "iron man" Stalin. He is the man who sacrificed his countrymen and then rewarded them with Siberia. How a country that has suffered and lost so much to this man, tolerates those that espouse going back to that kind of life is beyond my comprehension.

Vladimir Val Cymbal
Tarzana California
[04:03 03/05/2008] : Recommended reading:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes Terror ...
These genocidal thugs killed more than 100 million innocent people worldwide during their reign.
Still full of bloodlust for more death and destruction?
Enough of Communist terror!!!
Thomas Infidel
New Orleans
[19:28 03/05/2008] : To my fellow letter-writer: I say boohoohoo, and I also have a nice violin solo for you honey!
The commies banned all political parties during their 40 years of terror in Czechoslovakia,and KCM is advocating return of the Red Terror. They have no place in democratic country.
KSCM should be also banned, like the NSDAP, since they have basically the same idealogy!
Ivan Mirka
Toronto
[14:08 05/05/2008] : "There really are many different political views in the United States, but the two dominant parties play toward the middle to get 51 percent of the vote."

No, they play toward the middle because otherwise they wouldn't be allowed to take part in the election.

As for all your criticisms of the USSR: perhaps you have "forgotten" that your country was an ally of the Soviet Union.
Margot Winston
Prague
[15:57 05/05/2008] : "A system that has sapped the spirit of entrepreneurism, created an atmosphere for corruption, incarcerated millions, and murdered millions more."

This sounds much like the United States. Large unregulated cartels control much of its economy; the Congress is corrupt beyond belief; 1 percent of its entire population is behind bars (far more, per head of population than any other country in the world) and it has murdered millions of people around the world.

And unlike the former USSR, the regime in the United States is still in power.
Margot Winston
Prague
[16:25 05/05/2008] : My head is spinning from the silliness of my fellow letter-writer.

When someone is on the ballot from the Communist party, the Green party, the Libertarian party, etc., they are hardly playing toward to middle, but they are part of the election.
There is simply no logic in your statement.

Actually, I do not believe that I have ever criticized the USSR (at least not directly - today's Russia is not the USSR and in theory today's Russia is a democracy).
With this correction clarified, let's face it, we were allies with the Soviets to defeat Hitler.
Once World War II was over, we immediately were at odds with the Soviets.
There is a well-known statement in times of crisis "The enemy of my enemy is my friend", but it would be more prudent if politicoans remembered that sometimes "The enemy of my enemy is my enemy".
General George Patton knew this, even if Churchill and Roosevelt were willing to look the other way.
Richard Elliot
Charlotte
[21:47 05/05/2008] : More verbose childish remarks against the United States from you know who. She is always quick to try to snag an audience for her cause...but once again has made it clear that it is only based upon personal bad experiences and not education.
Philip
San Fran
[10:52 06/05/2008] : It's a pity that nobody can actually counter my arguments with facts: "my head is spinning with the silliness..." doesn't really contribute much to the discussion.
Margot Winston
Prague
[16:06 06/05/2008] : Satire ;-) and facts were conveyed.
Richard Elliot
Charlotte
[18:50 06/05/2008] : What would you call any person who joined the political party of a foreign power that invaded and occupied your country for 50 years?
They call people like that traitors.
The Czech communists are exactly that, traitors to their own country. If they want to be communists and puppets of the Russians, they only need to move to Russia.
Otherwise, they belong on trial for trying to overthrow their elected constitutional government and promoting Russia's political agenda in the Czech Republic.
John Kennedy
Sewell
[02:15 08/05/2008] : Ms. Winston confuses argument with opinion. The former is an interpretation of facts, while the latter does not require facts, and is all any of her comments ever consist of. Moreover, her repeated attacks on the US undermine her ability to persuade anyone that she is anything but an "America Basher" who accepts any excuse to engage in her favorite pastime.
Phillip David Haskett
Houston
[00:55 11/05/2008] : To my fellow letter-writer,
Do you even have any idea what life was like under the socialist government of the CSSR? Obviously not.
Well, I do. I lived under it for 15 years, then when my mother and I managed to escape. We met whole families in a refugee camp in Austria where people said: I left everything over there (CSSR) I just could not take it anymore (I felt stifled).
People left furnished apartments and houses just to be free.
Can you understand that?
Then, when the Berlin Wall came down, and barbed wire around the border was removed, people rejoiced and celebrated on top of the wall and in Wenceslas Square.
Karel Vrany
Orlando FL
Note: Comments that include profanity, personal attacks or any other inappropriate material are prohibited.  

Add your comment


Full Name: *
City: *
E-mail: **
This comment can be published in the print version of The Prague Post
Enter the text on the right:
visual captcha
Comment: *
* Required field. In order to be approved for display, comments must have a first and last name and a city.
** E-mails are required and will only be used for internal purposes.

Most visited in Book of Lists


The Prague Post Online contains a selection of articles that have been printed in
The Prague Post, a weekly newspaper published in the Czech Republic.
To subscribe to the print paper, click here.
Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited.