The Prague Post
May 16th, 2008
Reader's SurveyNEW     Endowment Fund     Book of Lists ONLINE      Reservations      Classifieds    Subscriptions
Hotel Prague Centre


Shadow of a doubt

Top homicide detective has built a career on nailing the bad guys

By Will Tizard
Staff Writer, The Prague Post
September 20th, 2006 issue

Mareš at the scene of a New Year's Eve fight among a Belarusian, a Czech and a German at Můstek.
Josef Mareš lives in a Prague not like anyone else's. His is populated by the dead and the unseeing.

Walk with him down just about any thoroughfare in the center of town, and he'll point out where someone drew their last breath. "Prague's not New York yet," says the 42-year-old chief of criminal investigations for the Prague Police, but it's coming along, with 45 to 50 murders a year.

And, adds Mareš, "In Prague, you always get the interesting ones."

The trim and chiseled top detective, who favors Nike tennis shoes, black jeans and polo shirts and does not allow his face in the papers, knows of what he speaks.

Having studied mechanical engineering in university, Mareš made the switch to law enforcement after the Velvet Revolution in 1990. It was a tumultuous time, he recalls, with the entire structure and role of the police in rapid transition; the guardians of the state were learning to be protectors of the public.

It's a transition still in progress, say some, but Mareš proved to be just the sort of fresh blood the lumbering Prague force needed. In three short years, he made it to homicide, the division every ambitious cop dreams of.

By 2000, Mareš was chief of the 40-officer homicide section, made up of colleagues whose average age is 50, some of whom have been there 20 years. Earlier this year, he rose to chief of criminal investigations, where he now supervises 600 officers.

It's not something you'd guess from a look around his cramped Prague 2 office: the standard-issue municipal rabbit hole in a grim concrete tower, complete with glass-fronted cabinets along the walls, an institutional-style desk and a scrawny plant or two fighting for life.

A few décor choices do make it unique, however, such as the Chinese ornamental machete he keeps as a prize from a gang fight in which a man was badly hacked. ("When Czechs argue, they might slap each other," Mareš says, "but these guys from the former Eastern bloc get out the knives.")

There's also a set of nunchakus, a skull (presumably a model) and an oversize Staropramen mug on the wall cabinet. A VCR and small television sit near the desk, on which one of the most respected cops in the country studies evidence footage from crime scenes. At the moment, he's playing a cassette of a soft-spoken professor who eventually got 10 years for pushing his wife out a window.

In His Words

The case of the falling woman

The case that offered me the most satisfaction was that of the woman who fell out of the window of her seventh-floor apartment in 2001. The case was thought to be an accident. I had some free time back then and went back to the scene and found out the case was not all that simple. I worked on the case on my own, and it was interesting having the chance to use new methods. In the end, I conducted a reconstruction test that simulated the woman's fall with the help of a firefighter who was tied to a rope and pushed out the same window. Had it been an accident, she would have landed much closer to the house. In the long run we managed to prove that it was a murder.
Her husband was suspected from the start. The problem was to prove it. The interesting thing about this case was that her husband was half-paralyzed after a stroke, and it was technically very difficult for him to throw his wife out of the window. The husband claimed he wasn't strong enough to do this. I wanted to carry out a reconstruction that would prove he really did it.
The husband described how he saw it happen. His wife was fixing ropes outside the window for hanging laundry. The reconstruction was done in the husband's presence, and from the way her husband described it, she could never fall out that way. And from where he was sitting at the time, we saw it was impossible for him to have seen it happen.
He was an intelligent person, a university professor in mechanical engineering. He ran as Václav Havel's only competition in the 1993 presidential election.
I offered him the chance to participate in the reconstruction, but he refused. We tried the fall a few times, and then other possibilities, like if the woman had fainted, but it was never the case that she'd fall out the window the way her husband claimed that she did.
This was like a Columbo case. I visited the man every second day, asked him for further explanation, telling him my boss wanted me to do paperwork and fill in whether she jumped herself or whether it was an accident. I asked him over and over again to repeat his version.
It was confirmed on a lie detector that at the moment of her death they had had an argument. We demonstrated how her fall must have happened, and the husband was sentenced, based on this evidence, to 10 years in prison.

"You'd never have guessed he was a killer," he says quietly. "The media didn't show any interest in the case. I feel that if I hadn't gone there at the time to investigate, the murder would have never been punished. The local department would file it as an accident, and that's where it would end."

As in most cities, 99 percent of homicides are clear-cut cases of violent death, Mareš explains. This one was classed an accidental fall until he began reviewing the details and noticed an odd problem. How does an elderly woman, falling by accident while hanging out the laundry to dry, land 7 meters (23 feet) from her wall?

To find out, Mareš visited the scene of the crime several times, each time asking a bit more about who was where when it happened, finally bringing in his video camera and a firefighter to simulate the fall while suspended by ropes. (For more details, see "In His Words.")

The killer's face began to tell as much as the climber's movements, recalls Mareš, chuckling as the tape rolls.

It turns out a working knowledge of biomechanics can be an asset in police business.

"Every murder case is different, and that's what's beautiful about it. You can never tell in advance whether it will be simple or complicated."

Take the Orlík reservoir murders, for example, which inspired the less-than-inspiring Czech film Velvet Murderers. In that case, in which an unrelated investigation led to the discovery that several bodies had been dumped at Orlík in oil drums in 1995, Mareš learned a lesson he'll never forget about how badly the media can screw up a case.

"We worked undercover, posing as environmentalists," he said about police efforts to check out the reservoir in south Bohemia. "Nobody knew we were police officers. However, TV Nova showed up at the scene on Saturday with no idea what we were looking for, but they did know we were the police — I don't know who told them."

Shaking his head, he recalls, "It was on television. We had witnesses with us who were instantly endangered by this, as the culprits were still running free. I didn't sleep for two days, stayed in my office, filing house-search and arrest warrants." All this because the media smelled a hot story.

"On the other hand," he says, "we do need the media when publishing information or photos and asking for witnesses to offer their testimony."

Earlier this year, Mareš says media coverage indeed paid off with the arrest of "a Slovak peroxide blonde," who, with her lover, was a traveling performer who had plotted to separate a retired Italian cop living in Prague from his life savings.

"We worked really long on that case. We knew who the culprit was, we had her picture, her image appeared on television and in press, and then the circus owner called to say that they were with his circus."

The Prague murder clearance rates are something to be proud of, Mareš says, particularly in that killings have become more violent and more are tied to gangs these days than ever before. In the past year, four murders resulted from robberies; none did in 2004.

All in all, it's a job that demands an unconventional mind and the energy of a man in his prime. The city can breathe a sigh of relief in that respect, at least.

For the foreseeable future, anyone thinking about taking an enemy out of the picture will find himself going up against a calm, cool cop who doesn't flinch.

And that, as we've seen, can clearly be murder.

Will Tizard can be reached at wtizard@praguepost.com


survey banner


Other articles in Tempo (20/09/2006):

Browse the Current Issue

If you enjoyed this article, why don't you subscribe to the print version!
We accept secure online transactions provided by PayPal and Moneybookers

Be the first to add a comment!


Full Name: *
City: *
E-mail: **
This comment can be published in the print version of The Prague Post
Enter the text on the right:
visual captcha
Comment: *
* Required field. In order to be approved for display, comments must have a first and last name and a city.
** E-mails are required and will only be used for internal purposes.
Most e-mailed articles
Related articles

Most visited in Book of Lists


The Prague Post Online contains a selection of articles that have been printed in
The Prague Post, a weekly newspaper published in the Czech Republic.
To subscribe to the print paper, click here.
Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited.