The Prague Post
May 12th, 2008
Real Estate Prague Prague Rentals Prague Apartments Prague Art & Antiques

Tougher tourist monitoring urged

Americans, Canadians and Australians are singled out

By Jeffrey White
Staff Writer, The Prague Post
March 22, 2006

The Foreign Affairs Ministry's promise to toughen monitoring of visitors from the United States, Canada and Australia has sent confusion and anxiety rippling through the tourism industry, even as some government officials say any such crackdown is logistically unfeasible.

Foreign Affairs Minister Cyril Svoboda told reporters March 19 that the Czech Republic needs to step up checks on tourists from these countries to confirm whether their passports have been properly stamped, whether they have enough money to cover their stay and whether they have health insurance coverage of at least $35,000 (833,700 Kč).

"We seriously suspect these rules are being massively violated," he said.

Czechs need a visa to visit the three countries named — a major sore spot among the government and residents. In contrast, Americans, Canadians and Australians do not need visa for stays up to 90 days in the Czech Republic. Svoboda, while demanding that the European Union renew pressure on those countries to relax visa restrictions for Czechs, hinted that many Westerners stay beyond 90 days and some obtain work here illegally.

His remarks were seen largely as a slap in the face of the United States, which the government considers as having by far the worst record of the three countries named for granting Czechs visas. And Svoboda's statements came just as a major five-day convention of U.S. travel agents convened in Prague March 21.

VISA WOES

- Americans, Canadians and Australians can visit the Czech Republic for up to 90 days, provided they get a valid stamp in their passport indicating the start of their stay

- Foreign Affairs Ministry says many do not obtain these stamps. It adds that the country needs to begin verifying whether these visitors have adequate money for their stay and health insurance coverage up to $35,000 (833,700 Kč)

A March 22 seminar at the conference was titled: "Getting More Business from the United States."

Conference attendees were forwarded a letter from CzechTourism before their arrival here, saying, among other things, to be prepared to show proof of travel insurance covering them for at least $30,000.

In an interview with The Prague Post, Rostislav Vondruška of CzechTourism said Svoboda's comments, if backed by actual enforcement measures, would affect tourism. No such implementation plan has been announced yet, however.

"The current [visa] situation is one-sidedly advantageous for American and Canadian tourists and quite humiliating for Czech citizens," Vondruška said.

The U.S. Embassy said 300,000 U.S. citizens visit the Czech Republic each year.

If each spent just $100 during his or her stay — a conservative estimate for even one day in Prague — the resulting $30 million translates into major cash flow for local businesses. U.S. citizens make up roughly 6 percent of all foreign tourists here, according to CzechTourism.

But if the tourism industry is waiting for fallout from Svoboda's statements, others are questioning just how genuine they were in the first place. In an election year it pays to resonate among voters, political analysts say, especially if you belong to the Christian Democrats, who are currently trailing in the polls.

"Definitely this is pre-election rhetoric," said observer Zdeněk Zbořil. "It's something Czech voters will love to hear, at least those who visit or want to visit the United States."

Even Prime Minister Jiří Paroubek, who said he supports Svoboda, added that "it is a pity" the foreign affairs minister decided to take this stand so close to June's election instead of a year ago.

But not everyone in the government is behind Svoboda. Interior Minister František Bublan, whose office oversees borders and customs, sharply criticized the foreign affairs minister, saying there is no feasible way to carry out such thorough monitoring of tourists. He added that all countries outside the EU should be treated equally.

Meanwhile Jan Krč, spokesman for the U.S. Embassy in Prague, has issued a conciliatory statement: "If the Czech Republic intends to institute special checks on its borders, it is their right to do so and we will respect that."

— Petr Kašpar contributed to this report.

Jeffrey White can be reached at jwhite@praguepost.com



Reader's Comments:
[30/03/2006] : The Czech government should realize that most travellers from Canada have travel insurance as part of credit card service. Not sure how they expect the border service to verify this fact.

The comment from Minister Svoboda was "well timed", considering that ASTA (American Society of Travel Agents) held a congress in Prague recently.

Instead of encouraging travel, his comment defeated the whole purpose of congress in the first place. That is - bring tourists who will stay longer, at better hotels and spend more money.
Stan Pavlik
Montreal
[28/03/2006] : While this is certainly pre-election xenophobic rhetoric, there is some truth to this. Those of you that have taken a trip down to the Foreigner Police office will know what I mean, e.g. mad shoving and pushing matches to be admitted into an office, long waits, etc. This office could easily install a take-a-number system used in most other Czech gov't offices today.

I suspect, the Czech gov't wants to discourage immigration into the country. Being dominated by foreign powers for hundreds of years has probably made some people here xenophobic. Of course, tourists - or rather their cash - will still be quite welcome.

The fact of the matter is that immigrants (at least those from Western countries) also hugely contribute to the Czech economy - most probably spend much more here than they ever earn here! And let's not forget about how all the multi-national firms here have provided hundreds of thousands of jobs for Czechs.

Yes, the US visa policy is one-sided, but that's because of 9/11. When a group of angry foreigners starts hijacking planes here and flying them into Prague Castle, then I would expect CR to also enact very strict immigration controls too! Let's hope something like that never happens, and the Czech gov't keeps a lid on the xenophobic elements in Czech society.
George Coppedge
Prague
[27/03/2006] : Yes Jane, the CIA funded Prague Post started this and now they must suffer like all hippie, backpacking, Americans!

Perhaps politicians like Svoboda are simply scoring political points because Americans have an idiot for president and because their visa situation is insulting to Czechs?


Miroslav Saman
Prague 5
[27/03/2006] : So what if it _is_ politics and the Czech government is fed up with Americans - I can easily understand why when you make arrogant, disparaging and over-generalised remarks claiming that American tourists are better than British or German ones. People don’t like people who think they’re better than they are.
Dave Clifton
Prague
[24/03/2006] : In follow up to Jane Carter's comment -- Whatever the number of illegal Americans currently in Prague, it is undoubtedly far lower than what it was in the mid-90s. Consequently, 10-year old estimates, even if accurate at the time (and the 40k figure always struck me as odd), are almost certainly no longer valid.

As unfair as the current U.S. visa policy may be (and I think that we can all agree that U.S. immigration is one of our worst-run bureaucracies), it boggles the mind that Mr. Svoboda would threaten to squelch such an important source of tourist income for the Czech Republic. I haven't heard of a crisis of penniless Americans flooding Czech public hospitals. The quality of the average visitor from the U.S. (in terms of spending power) is much better than it was ten years ago, and is by far better than the bands of binge drinkers and sex tourists that Prague gets all-too-frequently from Germany and the U.K.

No, this HAS to be politics. There's no other logical explanation for it.

Brant C. Hadaway
Miami, FL
[24/03/2006] : Minister Cyril Svoboda imbibes way too
much water from silver-wavey Vltava
River... we presume??? :-)
March 24, 2006
Jirina Fuchsova
Plzen/Los Angeles
[23/03/2006] : Unfortunately the Prague Post is directly responsible for this problem, although probably nobody presently working at your paper realises this.

About ten years ago The Prague Post made the ridiculous claim that there were "40,000 Americans in Prague". This figure was not based on any evidence, and has since been disproven (by your own paper). However it was taken up by some guide books, and even today some people actually believe it in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.

Unfortunately one of the people who did take it seriously was was a communist MEP [whose name I can't be bothered to look up]. He mentioned this figure in the course of the debate about Americans overstaying their 90-day stays in the country - essentially, one of the main reasons why the Czech Republic is scapegoating Americans is because many members of parliament now believe that there are 40,000 Americans living in the country. Since only about 2,500 of these are legal, the assumption is that there are tens of thousands who are here illegally. The true figure for illegal Americans is probably in the low hundreds.

Both myself and a friend of mine have written to Prague Post about this but both times our comments were censored. Given that you have caused so much trouble to so many people perhaps you could do the decent thing and a) refute your original claim and b) print this letter.

If you want to discuss this you can do so jane.c@runbox.com.
Jane Carter
Prague




The Prague Post Online contains a selection of articles that have been printed in
The Prague Post, a weekly newspaper published in the Czech Republic.
To subscribe to the print paper, click here.
Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited.